# workspace-cli AINative Review Hardening Final Review

- Review date: 2026-07-11
- Scope: requirement metadata and Review policies, clarification transaction, worker scheduling, provider lifecycle, capability and local file security
- Verdict: Approved; no blocking or important findings remain

## Results

- Migration 0005 is additive and preserves existing requirement rows with compatible defaults.
- Requirement submission and clarification persist acceptance criteria and priority; clarification field/repo changes share one transaction with approval response, job resume and audit events.
- Analysis and development policies can be managed through CLI/MCP and bound independently per requirement. Stage mismatches are rejected, referenced policies cannot be deleted, and `no_findings` is normalized to severity `none`.
- Worker capacity is `min(parallelism,max_workers)`. Pool polling continues while provider jobs run, and heartbeat refreshes both worker state and the owned job lease.
- Daemon-launched providers use the current workspace executable. Provider permission grants are consumed only after process start, and post-start failures terminate the process and finalize run/job state.
- Capabilities require an expiry. Sensitive configuration, database, runtime, MCP and output paths use owner-only permissions. Raw tail reads never exceed the requested byte limit.
- A cancellation race found by the race suite was fixed: daemon shutdown now treats context-cancellation errors from an in-flight tick/outcome as graceful termination.

## Verification

- `go test -count=1 ./...`: passed.
- `go test -race -count=1 ./...`: passed.
- `go vet ./...`: passed.
- `go build ./cmd/workspace`: passed.
- Built binary `init` and `mcp health`: passed with stdio transport and 33 tools.
- Real Codex provider smoke: passed.
- `git diff --check`: passed; `gofmt -l internal cmd`: empty.

## Batch Reviews

- [Requirement metadata and Review policy](ai-native-review-hardening-requirement-policy.md)
- [Worker scheduler](ai-native-review-hardening-worker-scheduler.md)
- [Provider lifecycle](ai-native-review-hardening-provider-lifecycle.md)
- [Capability and permissions](ai-native-review-hardening-capability-permissions.md)